A grassroots campaign to reduce flood risk in Nicasio has led to some significant victories, including the scrapping of a plan to dramatically expand the reservoir. But even as they celebrate some wins, residents are bracing for the looming super El Niño—and for more activism.

Over the last month, Marin Municipal Water District crews have cut back the thick canopy of willows whose branches crisscross Nicasio and Halleck Creeks, dropping debris during dry seasons…