After 34 years on the main street of Point Reyes Station, Zuma—a small shop devoted to handmade crafts from around the world—is closing.

“It’s so hard for me to leave this community,” said Melanie Stone, an Inverness resident who opened Zuma in 1993. “But it’s been many good years.” Ms. Stone is selling her inventory this month as she prepares to relocate to Alameda, where she will live with her son. 

Standing behind the…