Point Reyes Light - November 3, 2005

Please allow me to introduce myself

By Robert Plotkin

I am a former prosecutor and graduate of the Columbia School of Journalism. I have been published in The Jerusalem Post, San Francisco Chronicle, New York Observer, New York Times, Miami Herald and The Chicago Tribune. I have interviewed tank commanders surrounding Arafat’s Ramallah Compound, witnessed a suspected collaborator being shot in Jenin, and interviewed a Hamas leader in Gaza.

My political awakening took place during the Iranian hostage crisis of 1979, when I was a nine year old in San Diego. I felt trampled, abused, and impotent. Then, riding across the political chaparral, came a man with a jaunty pompadour and John Wayne worldview. I worked on the Reagan campaign and began a subscription to The National Review. My reading of William F. Buckley Jr. was syncopated with head nodding and cursed mutterings.

This went on until the eighth grade. It was then, after exhorting my fellow students to support the mining of Nicaraguan harbors, that a teacher forever changed my life. She walked into class and plopped a copy of Mother Jones onto my desk. Inside there was an article on Salvadoran death squads beheading villagers. There were families with heads cut off. It was a moment of intense clarity that instantly shattered my ideological force field. I began to read Mother Jones along with The National Review and then took up The Economist and The Nation.

Most of my political positions today would be characterized as liberal, but I never hew to a party line, never swallow a party platform whole. Ideological rigidity is not a virtue; nor is the inability to disagree civilly. Opening yourself to other viewpoints is not a weakness. Failure to do so ossifies the political animal until, over time, he becomes maladapted, still hunting for jungle prey long after the jungle has been clear-cut.

My boyhood home was modest. I think of it as pre-Vietnam War. The green, shag carpet was worn. The largest holes were covered with mismatched throw rugs. The deck had a foot-size hole in it from the jumping jacks of a weekend guest. The coffee table was the color of coffee, a selling point for clumsy, coffee drinking people. It permitted no boast, no sweep of the hand. It mocked pride.

My summers were spent with my grandparents in Israel. I would bring a suitcase of clothes and a suitcase of books. In sneakers and surfer shorts, I proclaimed my nationality among the sandals and Speedos.

Women with hairy moles pushed me out of bus lines. Chicken came from the butcher, bread from the baker, and medicine from the government. My grandparents helped me catch the comet tail of Yiddish. My contemporaries spoke Hebrew, so I conversed with the wizened and imported. Evenings were spent filtering English language news broadcasts from Tel Aviv and Beirut. News was balkanized and parochial. The pretense of objectivity was refreshingly absent.

During my college years I studied Third World economic development in Malaysian tin mines; Islamic Fundamentalism in Kashmir; poverty in the slums of Caracas. In Beijing, I took photographs that caught the unwanted attention of a Chinese intelligence officer. He forced me to mount the handlebars of his bicycle for a ride to a guard shack. I sat on the floor while Mandarin was shouted above me. It was there on the floor that I decided that, some day, I would be a foreign correspondent. Then I escaped.

After college, law school, and a federal judicial clerkship, I became a Deputy District Attorney for Monterey County. Essentially, my job was to read and evaluate police reports. If interminable negotiations failed, the file became a loose script for jury trial (i.e. several days of improvisational performance art).

In a prologue of frenzied activity, addresses became three dimensional, victims gained smell and patois, police no longer served as interlocutors. My experience was unmediated. Unfortunately, this represented a sliver of my time. Otherwise, I sat behind my desk and read police reports or mechanically attended to the banal.

This is why I left for Columbia Graduate School of Journalism, where I spent two years learning journalistic ethics that ill-served me in the world of commercial journalism where editorial timidity often prevailed. Public relation firms controlled the news cycle, and I did not.

So I brought my wife Lys, and son Max to Bolinas in order to pursue a career as a freelance foreign correspondent. Once here I discovered The Point Reyes Light and met Dave Mitchell, its valiant editor. I found this mighty-mite of a paper, with Pulitzer pedigree and low coffers. After a great deal of my plaintive wooing, Mitchell agreed to sell me The Light. He has deemed me worthy to carry on his extraordinary work, which – second to my wife agreeing to marrying me – is the highest compliment I have ever received.

 Point Reyes Light Cover | News | Coastal Traveler