Point Reyes Light - January 26, 2006

Nude protest against herbicide falters after low turnout

By Ashley Harrell

Catalphia Antelope of Inverness is not an exhibitionist. She grew up in conservative small-town Michigan and has never dressed provocatively. But when she heard that Donna Sheehan was planning a protest that involved spelling out "No 2,4-D," an herbicide, by arranging naked women in a field, she reached for the razor.

"I shaved a little bit down here — just for vanity," said Antelope, 64, tracing her pelvic bones beneath her sapphire cotton blouse. To assuage the hesitation over public nudity, Antelope consulted the I Ching and found the outcome "more auspicious," if she participated. And the cause — thwarting the aerial spraying of 2,4-D, which farmers hope will eradicate thistle in Valley Ford, Chileno Valley and Nicasio — finally trumped her modest nature.

Antelope took a hot shower, ate a hamburger (naturally raised beef) and packed her car with three towels in preparation for the disrobing.

"If I was going to lie down on the wet, cold earth, I wanted to be warm inside," she said, standing with her arms crossed on the side of road next to Love Field Wednesday afternoon. Turkey vultures circled overhead as a chilly breeze sifted through willow trees and blackberry bushes. The muddied baseball field, not yet recovered from the flood, did not look particularly inviting. But Antelope got to keep her clothes on after all.

Late notice

Only seven women showed up at the field, falling short of the 15 that organizer and life-long activist Donna Sheehan, 75, needed to decently spell out "No 2,4-D."

"I expected 278," Sheehan joked before calling off the protest, "but because it’s a cold day and it’s such late notice…"

Ironically, late notice was a big reason Sheehan called the protest on Tuesday morning. California does not require that the public be notified of 2,4-D sprayings and neither does Marin County, so Sheehan worried that people who hike and bicycle next to the farms might be unknowingly poisoned.

But Marin County Agricultural Commissioner Stacy Carlsen says there’s no need to inform the pubic of a rural 2,4-D spraying. "It’s not considered a hazard," he said. "People get a visual image of a helicopter applying vast materials over a large area, and that image is very perplexing to me…they’re only spraying 10 or 20 acres that are usually inaccessible to the farmer, so there’s no nexus between a public person and the site."

Sheehan’s naked protesters

It would have been the fifth time Sheehan rallied naked protesters, which she’s done in the past to criticize the Gap clothing store chain and the war in Iraq. In January of 2003, Sheehan’s "PEACE" formation, created by 45 naked ladies on the Point Reyes National Seashore, attracted international media attention. That wasn’t surprising to Sheehan, who perceives the media as male-dominated and therefore acquiescent to messages delivered via nude women.

"I believe it’s our biological power and it’s contributing to our femininity and self-esteem," she said. "We don’t use it often enough, politically."

Kate St. Clair, freckled and wearing a fake wolf’s head on top of her own head, agreed that the tactic could be used more often. "We grew up in the 60’s," she said. "We’ll take our clothes off at the drop of a hat."

Postscript

But they didn’t. In lieu of getting naked, the seven women and one man passionately discussed their views on everything from deodorant causing breast cancer to a sad vibe given off by certain cows. Jan Stewart, a Point Reyes Station photographer, passed out German chocolates that were not organic, but Paul Reffell of Marshall assured everyone that they were most likely "earth chocolates."

The crowd gradually dwindled, and the women said their goodbyes and promised to be back next time. Antelope lingered until the end, when the conversation turned to Latigresa, a Redwood woman known to write poetry and recite it, topless, to loggers.

"I wish I could be like that," Antelope said. "I’m glad I came today and I’m interested to see what happens next."

Point Reyes Light Cover | News | Coastal Traveler